tender · onsite

To procure consultancy for enhancing audit quality management , strengthen Performance audit function and citizen participatory audit (CPA) and enhancing the sustainable use of IT tools for audit management system in office of the Auditor

Contract Award Project: P164783-Integrated Public Financial Management Reform Project Loan/Credit/TF Info: TF-A7475 Bid/Contract Reference No: NP-OAGN-CS-1 Procurement Method: QCBS-Quality And Cost-Based Selection Scope of Contract: Consulting Services for Strengthening the Office of the Auditor General Notice Version No: 0 Contract Signature Date (YYYY/MM/DD) 2019/08/29 Duration of Contract 2 Year(s) Minimum Qualifying Score 70 Awarded Firm(s): ERNST & YOUNG LLP(EY) (409171) 3rd &6th Floor,World Mark -1 IGI Airport Hospitality District ,Aericity, New Delhi,110037, India Country: India Scores Technical: 73.05 Consultant Specific Experience: 5.00 Methodology: 20.10 Key Personnel: 39.95 Transfer of Knowledge: 4.00 Participation by Nationals: 4.00 Financial: 19.07 Combined: 77.51 Rank: 1 Final Evaluation Price NPR 156,614,958.00 Signed Contract Price USD 1,583,243.00 Evaluated Firm(s): PRICE WATER HOUSE COOPERS PVT. LTD. (387225) 17th Floor, Building 10C, DLF Cyber City Guragaon-1222002, Haryana Country: India Scores Technical: 75.85 Consultant Specific Experience: 5.00 Methodology: 22.00 Key Personnel: 40.65 Transfer of Knowledge: 3.80 Participation by Nationals: 4.40 Financial: 12.66 Combined: 73.34 Rank: 4 Final Evaluation Price NPR 235,905,206.80 DELOITTE TOUCHE TOHMATSU INDIA LLP (379710) Bengal Intelligent Park, Building Omega 14th Floor, Block EP & GP sector - V, Kolkata - 700091, India Country: India Scores Technical: 71.25 Consultant Specific Experience: 5.00 Methodology: 19.50 Key Personnel: 37.55 Transfer of Knowledge: 4.80 Participation by Nationals: 4.40 Financial: 20 Combined: 77 Rank: 2 Final Evaluation Price NPR 149,351,769.70 COWATER SOGEMA (395678) 275 Slater Street, Suite 1600 Ottawa Ontario Canada,K1P5H9 Country: Canada Scores Technical: 77.30 Consultant Specific Experience: 5.00 Methodology: 22.40 Key Personnel: 41.30 Transfer of Knowledge: 4.20 Participation by Nationals: 4.40 Financial: 14.92 Combined: 76.76 Rank: 3 Final Evaluation Price NPR 200,142,090.00 KPMG ADVISORY SERVICES PVT LTD (326113) BUILDING NO. 10, 8TH FLOOR, TOWER - B DLF CYBER CITY, PHASE - II, GURGAON 122002 HARYANA INDIA Country: India Scores Technical: 72.15 Consultant Specific Experience: 5.00 Methodology: 20.80 Key Personnel: 37.55 Transfer of Knowledge: 4.20 Participation by Nationals: 4.60 Financial: 13.18 Combined: 70.90 Rank: 5 Final Evaluation Price NPR 226,676,670.66 CROWN AGENTS (408014) Blue mFin Building 110 SouthwarkStreeet, UK 08065294600 Country: United Kingdom Scores Technical: 75.85 Consultant Specific Experience: 5.00 Methodology: 20.60 Key Personnel: 41.25 Transfer of Knowledge: 4.60 Participation by Nationals: 4.40 Financial: 8.48 Combined: 69.16 Rank: 6 Final Evaluation Price NPR 352,210,663.90 Rejected Firm(s): IPE GLOBAL LIMITED (329804) IPE GLOBAL HOUSE, B-84, DEFENCE COLONY, NEW DELHI-110 024,INDIA Country: India BDO LLP (376429) Country: United Kingdom Scores Technical: 64.85 Consultant Specific Experience: 5.00 Methodology: 21.00 Key Personnel: 31.85 Transfer of Knowledge: 3.80 Participation by Nationals: 3.20 Final Evaluation Price Reason for Rejection Non Responsive